Headframe Coffee Blends History and Community

by Kurt Geinsheimer

It might not seem evident at first, but there is a distinct connection between hard rock mining and a cup of coffee. Both involve refining processes, and through chemical reactions, both go from raw materials to a finished product, morphing into things we consume and enjoy on a daily basis. But for Polly Alstatt, the connection between mining and coffee runs much deeper. 

“It’s a blend of culture connected to the working class,” said Alstatt, owner of Headframe Coffee in Ely. 

Alstatt’s personality percolates like fresh brewed coffee, her enthusiasm for the beverage is evident as soon you walk in the door of her roastery at 417 Murry Street. Since her first summer job at age 15, working at a coffee house in Ouray, Colorado, Alstatt has been passionate about quality coffee, sharing that passion with likeminded folks while educating the uninitiated.

Alstatt opened Headframe Coffee on Thanksgiving Day 2024 as a small-batch roastery focused on blending and roasting the highest quality coffee possible. In addition to being a new business owner, Alstatt works full-time at the Robinson Mine in Ruth as a warranty repair planner. Alstatt, a Colorado native, is a fourth generation miner; her grandfather operated uranium mines in Silverton and Ouray, and her father mined gold and coal. 

This combined lineage in mining and passion for coffee was the foundation for Alstatt creating Headframe Coffee. Alstatt always knew she wanted to go with a mining theme for her roastery, and was originally going to call the business the Coffee Mine, but the name was already taken. So Alstatt gave some serious thought to what she loves most about mining, and the image of a headframe – the tall timber structure above a mine shaft – came into focus.

“A headframe all lit up at Christmas is one of the best things ever,” said Alstatt, with the dream of one day having a building with a giant headframe at the entrance. 

What motivated Alstatt to start a new business while having a full-time job and caring for two of her five children? 

“It was always a dream, it was a calling,” said Alstatt. “Coffee is all about connection on a deep level. It’s almost like a comfort, a healing, where people can open up, share and support each other. Coffee has always been that for me.”

Part of that dream is taking Headframe Coffee beyond just a roastery. Ultimately, Alstatt wants Headframe to incorporate a proper coffee house. What is the difference between a coffee shop and a coffee house?

“Quality, integrity, connection and comfort,” said Alstatt. “It’s a place where people can connect, whether you’re a hard rock miner, a millionaire, a small business owner or a stay-at-home mom.”

Alstatt opened the roastery first because she wanted organic, high-end specialty coffee, educating customers about the differences between blends and roasts, and what separates grocery store bought coffee from the specialty coffees Alstatt produces by hand in small batches. All of her beans start raw, in a “green” state, and are roasted by temperature, eyesight and smell, exactly to how a customer wants it. She sources her beans from around the world and blends them herself. None of these things you get form store bought coffee.

“Pay attention the next time you are buying coffee in the bag at a grocery store,” said Alstatt. “What are you picking up? Is it because of the fancy label? Is there a roast date? It’s interesting to see what people choose.”

According to Alstatt, simplicity is the key to coffee. Headframe Coffee bags are very simple, with just the stamped logo and a roast date. Alstatt believes the biggest mistake people make with coffee is they make it too difficult. 

“Just like connection, coffee is simple,” said Alstatt. “Take a step back, enjoy the process and let coffee do its thing. Sometimes you don’t need to add anything to it.”

Although Alstatt is relatively new to the Ely community, due to her knowledge of mining history and her love of the outdoors, she has settled in quickly. 

“I love the mountains, water, wildlife and trees, and Ely is just big enough of a town to meet the needs of my daughter who has special needs.”

Another central element to starting Headframe Coffee is creating a local employer who provides permanent, long-term opportunities to those in the community with special needs. Alstatt’s goal is to help establish independence for those with special needs through meaningful employment.

Alstatt also wants to help create a town of coffee aficionados, showing her customers the difference in quality compared to coffee bought in a grocery store. Customers come into Headframe not realizing how vast of a difference the taste and aroma of a coffee can be until Alstatt shows them her process and the resulting product. A critical part of that process is the type of grind. 

“Changing the grind can change everything about the taste,” said Alstatt. “What do you want to pull from the coffee? Do you want a sweeter, more earthy note? Most people don’t know because they are used to such bland coffee form the store. At Headframe there is experimentation and getting different flavors.” 

Although its new, Alstatt’s ornate San Franciscan coffee roaster looks old world, adorned with copper plating and iron, something straight out of 19th century, customized to emulate the Nevada Northern Railway steam train. Alstatt roasts every batch by hand, six pounds at a time, relying on her nose and eyes to gauge when a roast is just right.

Before starting Headframe, Alstatt took 18 months to perfect her blends, giving out more than 300 pounds of coffee before settling on her main blends. Alstatt sources all the beans, then blends them herself to produce a unique product unlike anything else. And judging by Alstatt’s growing list of new and returning customers, Ely residents are valuing the quality coffees Headframe produces.

Ely residents also value the mining history theme of Headframe Coffee. Alstatt has always been a mining history buff, and knew a bit about Ely’s history, but she didn’t fully realize how pivotal the railroad was and the town’s importance in building America’s copper infrastructure.

“Gold is cool, but copper has so much more in your face application daily that we don’t realize,” said Alstatt. 

Education is another component Alstatt is incorporating into Headframe’s brand. For example, each unique blend will be named with a different metal element from the periodic table. Alstatt has also had a lot of locals donating historic mining relics to the store. This combination of education and history is gives Headframe a deeper importance to the community. 

Although she is still relatively new to Ely, Alstatt sees herself staying here long term. 

“This community has been so good to me and my family,” said Alstatt. “The people here are incredible, and I want to serve them at the highest level I can.”

Disover Dining in Ely & White Pine County HERE!